31 Manhanset Road, Dering Harbor, NY 11964, Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States. - Hero Image
Property logo
31
Manhanset Road
Shelter Island Heights | New York

The Heart of

Villa Living

View More
Menu
Gary DePersia
Gary DePersia
Presented At
$2,895,000
31 Manhanset Road, Dering Harbor, NY 11964, Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States. - Photo 1
31 Manhanset Road, Dering Harbor, NY 11964, Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States. - Photo 2
31 Manhanset Road, Dering Harbor, NY 11964, Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States. - Photo 3
31 Manhanset Road, Dering Harbor, NY 11964, Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States. - Photo 4
31 Manhanset Road, Dering Harbor, NY 11964, Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States. - Photo 5
31 Manhanset Road, Dering Harbor, NY 11964, Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States. - Photo 6
31 Manhanset Road, Dering Harbor, NY 11964, Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States. - Photo 7
31 Manhanset Road, Dering Harbor, NY 11964, Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States. - Photo 8
31 Manhanset Road, Dering Harbor, NY 11964, Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States. - Photo 9
31 Manhanset Road, Dering Harbor, NY 11964, Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States. - Photo 10
31 Manhanset Road, Dering Harbor, NY 11964, Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States. - Photo 11
31 Manhanset Road, Dering Harbor, NY 11964, Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States. - Photo 12
31 Manhanset Road, Dering Harbor, NY 11964, Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States. - Photo 13
31 Manhanset Road, Dering Harbor, NY 11964, Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States. - Photo 14
31 Manhanset Road, Dering Harbor, NY 11964, Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States. - Photo 15
31 Manhanset Road, Dering Harbor, NY 11964, Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States. - Photo 16
31 Manhanset Road, Dering Harbor, NY 11964, Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States. - Photo 17
31 Manhanset Road, Dering Harbor, NY 11964, Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States. - Photo 18
Thumbnail 1
Thumbnail 2
Thumbnail 3
Thumbnail 4
Thumbnail 5
Thumbnail 6
Thumbnail 7
Thumbnail 8
Thumbnail 9
Thumbnail 10
Thumbnail 11
Thumbnail 12
Thumbnail 13
Thumbnail 14
Thumbnail 15
Thumbnail 16
Thumbnail 17
Thumbnail 18
31 Manhanset Road, Dering Harbor, NY 11964, Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States. , Shelter Island Heights , New York

About This Property

Tucked within the storybook charm of Dering Harbor-New York's smallest and arguably most exclusive village-lies a majestic 8.2-acre estate parcel waiting to be reimagined. With only 35 homes dotting this picturesque 200-acre seaside haven, the opportunity to claim such a vast and pristine canvas is nothing short of extraordinary. Once part of the legendary 'Oriole Farm,' the private arboretum and cultivated gardens of famed horticulturist Alice Fisk, this land is steeped in heritage and beauty. Now, for the first time in generations, this treasured property emerges from its quiet slumber to invite a visionary buyer to shape their own legacy in an unmatched setting. Surrounded by whispers of nature and the tranquility of the sea, the gently cleared land offers a rare combination of serenity and scale-with ample room to design a grand manor, shimmering pool, elegant pool house, tennis court, and even a bespoke carriage house with legal living quarters above. A discreet service entrance on the west side adds both convenience and privacy, and shortens your stroll to the village center. Unlike other areas on Shelter Island, Dering Harbor benefits from its own municipal water supply-ensuring both crystal-clear drinking water and a thriving landscape nourished year-round. Directly across from the verdant fairways of Gardiner's Bay Country Club, with views of the iconic 4th hole, the estate is perfectly positioned for those who appreciate refined leisure. Within a leisurely walk, you'll discover sandy beaches, charming shops, and fine dining tucked along the waterfront-each moment here infused with the idyllic pace of island life. With easy access to both the North and South Forks and the freedom to shape your vision while finalizing architectural plans, this singular offering invites you to craft something timeless-a sanctuary where nature, history, and elegance converge. Come walk the land, breathe in the salt air, and imagine the extraordinary life that awaits.

Gallery

Map showing 31 Manhanset Road, Dering Harbor, NY 11964, Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States.

Property Location

31 Manhanset Road, Dering Harbor, NY 11964, Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States., Shelter Island Heights New York

Local Weather & Climate

Shelter Island Heights, New York

Current Conditions Updated recently
14 °F
Scattered clouds
Feels Like 14°F
Humidity 43%
Wind 2 mph
Visibility 6.2 mi
Sunrise 12:07 PM
Sunset 9:55 PM
5-Day Forecast
Sun 25 Jan
Clouds
High 24°
Low 14°
Mon 26 Jan
Snow
High 33°
Low 28°
Tue 27 Jan
Clouds
High 26°
Low 20°
Wed 28 Jan
Clouds
High 26°
Low 18°
Thu 29 Jan
Clouds
High 27°
Low 23°
Data from OpenWeatherMap

Walkability & Transit Scores

How easy is it to get around Shelter Island Heights?

Walkability and transit scores for this address come from the EPA National Walkability Index.

Mortgage Calculator

Estimate your monthly payments for this property

$
%
$100,000
%
Estimated Monthly Payment $3,160
Monthly Payment Breakdown
Principal & Interest $2,528
Loan Amount $400,000
Total Interest $337,621
Total Cost $737,621
Potential Tax Benefits (United States)
$0 Est. First Year Interest Deduction
$0 Est. Annual Tax Savings
*Based on post-2017 tax law. Actual deductions depend on filing status, itemization, and current tax laws.

Ready to explore financing?

Connect with trusted mortgage partners

Important Information
  • This calculator is for illustrative purposes only and does not constitute a loan offer, pre-approval, or commitment to lend.
  • Monthly payment estimates do not include property taxes, homeowner's insurance, HOA fees, or other applicable costs which may significantly increase your actual payment.
  • Interest rates shown are for demonstration only. Actual rates depend on your credit score, down payment, loan type, property location, and current market conditions.
  • This tool provides estimates only. Consult with a licensed mortgage professional for accurate quotes and personalized advice.
  • Tax benefit calculations are simplified estimates based on general assumptions for United States. Actual deductions depend on your specific tax situation, filing status, and current tax laws.
  • Tax Year Information: Tax data shown is based on United States tax year 2025 (fiscal year: January-December), rules effective from 2018 through 2025. Tax laws change frequently and may have been amended since this data was compiled.

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about this property

This property is listed at $289,500,000.
This is a land parcel located in Shelter Island Heights, New York. The property is situated in an established neighborhood with convenient access to local amenities and services.
Gary DePersia

Gary DePersia

Corcoran East Hampton

License #02205397

View Full Profile

Schedule a Tour

Get in touch with our listing agents

SunMonTueWedThuFriSat

More Listings

Explore more properties

Official Real Estate Games

Have fun discovering more properties while playing our real estate games — win prizes for ranking high!

$
$
$
$
$
$
$
WIN CREDITS
Up Your Real Estate Skills FOR FREE

Loading listings...